Sep 12, 2026 10:00pm IST
‘The Secret Woman’ Review: A Promising Mystery That Never Finds Its Thrill
Although the Danish thriller “The Secret Woman” (“Den hemmelige kvinde”) dropped on Netflix without much noise, it rose to the top spot on the non-English film list with 19.3 million views, which saw it become part of social media conversations and recommendations. Some compared it to “Gone Girl” (2014). The English film, which is counted among the best thrillers, starred Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike. “The Secret Woman” is based on a Danish novel by Anna Ekberg, a pseudonym. The book was actually written by the Danish male writing duo Jacob Weinreich and Anders Rønnow Klarlund.
The film revolves around Louise Andersen (Natalie Madueño), who lives a quiet, happy life on the Norwegian island of Hidra with her boyfriend, Joachim (Pål Sverre Hagen), where they run a small café. They get engaged at home, surrounded by friends. But her life changes when a stranger approaches her and insists that she is actually Helene Söderberg, a Danish heiress who mysteriously disappeared three years earlier.
Related Stories
Helene belongs to a powerful family that runs a shipping empire. is married to wealthy businessman Edmund Söderberg (Claes Bang) and has a son, Alexander, with him. The family of three lives in Helene’s childhood mansion with Edmund’s mother, Caroline (Stina Ekblad). When Helene returns to her family home, things are hunky-dory at the beginning, but she eventually realizes that nothing is as it seems. Her quest to uncover the truth is what drives the narrative.
On paper, “The Secret Woman” has all the ingredients of a gripping domestic noir: a missing heiress, a mysterious return, a wealthy family harboring secrets and a protagonist struggling with her own identity. The obvious question that arises as the 119-minute movie unfolds is whether Helene is faking her amnesia. The domestic-noir element never manages to build the tension in a way that will have you holding your breath.
The biggest problem is that the characters themselves rarely feel layered enough to sustain the mystery. Almost everyone operates at the same emotional pitch, making the performances feel competent but monotone. There is little volatility or ambiguity in their behavior, and the film never makes you question who deserves your sympathy or whether you should be rooting for one character over another.
The film also severely lacks world-building. The wealthy Söderberg family, their shipping empire and the mansion they inhabit never really convey the claustrophobic feel it should once the sun sets. As a result, the mansion feels more like a backdrop than a character. While Edmund constantly gaslights his wife, he also pretty much lets her pursue her investigation without much effort to put the brakes on it, apart from having her followed down one alley and a little help from some pills and a hospitalization.
There is nothing particularly wrong with the performances. But the actors are working with characters that have been written with little emotional variation, leaving them with limited room to create intrigue. For a film that relies so heavily on questions of identity, deception and trust, “The Secret Woman” frustratingly gives us very few reasons to become emotionally invested in the people at its center.
Ultimately, it has a premise that promises a deliciously dark thriller, but the execution is too restrained and predictable to deliver on it. It has the ingredients for a compelling mystery, but never quite finds the atmosphere, character complexity or tension needed to allow them to blend. While the film is watchable, comparisons to “Gone Girl” are hugely unfair to the latter.
Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.