‘Guarding Stars’ Review: Leighton Meester, Jared Padalecki Keep This Christmas Rom-Com Warm, Fuzzy and Enjoyable
Jinal Bhatt
- ‘Guarding Stars’ Review: Leighton Meester, Jared Padalecki Keep This Christmas Rom-Com Warm, Fuzzy and Enjoyable
- Yaga’ Intimacy Coordinator Amanda Cutting on Crafting Sensuous, Edgy Sex Scenes: ‘The Female Gaze Was a Priority For the Entire Team’ (EXCLUSIVE)
- Ali Fazal, Fiona Shaw, Naseeruddin Shah, Tom Mison Lead Richie Mehta’s ‘A Passage to India’ Series for BBC, CBC
- Robert Pattinson Welcomed as the New James Bond by the British Royal Family, Former 007 George Lazenby, Bond Villain Kabir Bedi and More
- Robert Pattinson Is Officially James Bond: Meet the New 007 Actor
Latest
“Guarding Stars” is my least favorite assignment,” remarks Hannah Brooks, played by Leighton Meester (“Gossip Girl”), quite early on in the film. The private security agency she works for assigns her to protect Jack Stapleton, played by Jared Padalecki (“Gilmore Girls,” “Supernatural”). He is Hollywood’s biggest action star, and as we are repeatedly reminded through dialogue and visual cues, PEOPLE magazine’s Sexiest Man Alive. A million girls would kill for this job, but of course, only the “pocket-sized” Hannah has the military training and sharp instincts to really get the job done of protecting this 6’5” hunk.
Based on Katherine Center’s 2022 romance novel, “The Bodyguard,” “Guarding Stars,” directed by Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum, is Netflix’s latest Christmas rom-com, with an all-too-familiar “city girl goes to a remote town for the holidays” premise. But as the trailer reveals, the film flips a few gender tropes on their head for a slightly more novel premise. Hollywood heartthrob Jack is due home in snowy Montana for Christmas and doesn’t want to worry his ailing mother (Andie MacDowell) and their family about a serious stalker threat. Naturally, Hannah ends up pretending she is Jack’s surprise new girlfriend after a bad breakup with a pop star, Kennedy (Ava Max), who has been writing diss tracks about him.
The fake dating soon gives way to prolonged eye contact, hidden smiles and deeply personal conversations. And, of course, there’s only one bed. The family — Jack’s mother Connie, his father Doc, younger brother Hank (Noah LaLonde), his wife Ella Mae (Siobhan Williams) and their two children — welcome Hannah home with open arms and thank her for bringing Jack back. But while outwardly it’s a picture of a happy home during Christmas, complete with a red, white, brown, and green façade, there’s unspoken friction between the brothers. Even Hannah is juggling difficult emotions due to her past, which makes being around Jack’s family a bittersweet experience.
Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki are easily the tree toppers of this holiday movie that seems to flit between genres unexpectedly. Overarching, it’s a typical, trope-y Christmas romance with corny moments that will make you smile despite all the self-awareness. But occasionally, and unexpectedly, it remembers there’s a stalker threat for Jack or that Hannah might have PTSD from her Afghanistan military tour, and things kick into heavy emotion and action gear. It might feel a little jarring at first, but it’s never out of place because some of the best acting moments from Meester and Padalecki arrive in scenes where they flex their emotional chops, honed after years of playing layered characters like Blair Waldorf on “Gossip Girl” and Sam Winchester in “Supernatural.” These emotional moments are dealt with rather swiftly, and tempered with humor almost instantly.
Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum, who previously directed the Sofia Carson and Nicholas Galitzine-starrer adaptation of “Purple Hearts,” knows how to shift from casual romantic moments to intense ones, while keeping the focus on her lead actors’ faces, which works in the film’s favor. Meester, with her microexpressions and body language, conveys the intricacies of Hannah’s grief and trauma, like the scene where she must leave the Stapleton ranch after her assignment. She’s equally effective at delivering the sass and wit in their banter. Padalecki effortlessly exudes that casual, likable Hollywood-star charm and penchant for rule-breaking without making Jack seem annoying or so down-to-earth that you forget he is a film star. He nails the look of love: That softened expression mingled with awe every time the petite Hannah saves the day.
Popular on Variety
The couple’s chemistry carries the film’s mostly serviceable writing (Erin Cardillo and Richard Keith), which keeps it tight and easy-flowing for its under-two-hour runtime. The supporting cast does a great job of anchoring the background. Andie MacDowell sells the sweet matriarch vibe, around whom the rest of the family gathers. And Noah LaLonde, star of Netflix’s “My Life with the Walter Boys,” has plenty of experience playing a character who fights with the brother he secretly loves most. He even gets to compete in a rodeo event, which feels like the perfect nod to the YA series.
“Guarding Stars” makes some fitting casting choices, too. American pro wrestler CM Punk is perfect as Hannah’s fellow “executive protection agent”. And country singer Walker Hayes gets to croon as the karaoke-loving Sheriff Sanderson atop the Christmas Day parade float in the climax. The film even manages a sweet nod to Padalecki’s real life as well as to “Supernatural,” the show he spent over 15 years of his life making. Jack sings a song about Santa loving pie, just like the actor’s on-screen brother, Dean Winchester, played by Jensen Ackles, is known to do. In the same scene, as everyone takes turns coming up with absurd pies, Meester suggests “Moose,” which fans will recognize as Sam Winchester’s nickname from the cult series.
“Guarding Stars” is a perfectly enjoyable treat for fans of the genre and its lead actors, and one of the better Christmas rom-coms of the year.
Read More About: Christmas, Christmas movies, Gilmore Girls, Gossip Girl, Guarding Stars, Jared Padalecki, Leighton Meester, Netflix, romcom, Supernatural
By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Service and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.














Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.